Dareka no Manazashi Review

https://i.pinimg.com/474x/1e/82/a9/1e82a99d2b573197396cb53d58be32f2--watch-otaku.jpg
AKA: Someone’s Gaze
Genre: Slice-of-life/Sci-Fi/Drama
Year Released: 2013

Distributor: Unlicensed

Origin: Japan

Running Time: 7 minutes

Rating/Recommended Audience: G

Related Films/Series: N/A
For Fans Of: She and Her Cat, 5 Centimeters Per Second
Notes: N/A

Fun Facts:

-Dareka no Manazashi was created with help from the Nomura Real Estate Group and it was promoted to spotlight some homes in the Tokyo area. Imagine if someone like Re/max or Century 21 decided to bankroll an animated short film over here.

-This is the 2nd Makoto Shinkai production that involved Satomi Hanamura who voices the main character Aya. She was previously in 5 Centimeters Per Second as Kanae.

-Speaking of voice actresses, the narrator is played by Fumi Hirano who’s best known for playing Lum Invader from the Urusei Yatsura series.


I must be on a roll by covering several of Makoto Shinkai’s works. Maybe it was my former otaku self pining for more of his work especially as I checked out things from his later filmography. I didn’t realize he made a very short film much like his debut work She and Her Cat.



Dareka no Manazashi takes place in the near future where a young woman named Aya Okamura gets her own place quite recently. She recently got a job away from her home, but Aya had issues at her job as her boss yelled at her. The home life of the Okamura’s had plenty of distance. Her father still lives at the old house with their aging cat Mii while his wife works overseas. Despite Aya’s independence, she still longs to visit home and to see her family reunite for once.

Shinkai, you really know how to hit people in the feels in several of your movies. That emotional edge certainly continues the trend here. The situation presented is quite relatable despite some of the futuristic technology present (which looks unintentionally more high tech than Voices of a Distant Star despite presumably taking place before that short film). I know everybody has experienced that one bad day at work where the boss gives someone crap. Trust me, I’ve been there in previous jobs. The theme of distance is another trademark Shinkai trope. There’s Aya who’s away from the family home while her mom is away in another country due to her job. I wanted to see this family get together at the end for a brief reunion despite the very short run time. I also thought the ambiguous narrator was an interesting touch. I thought it was supposed to be the mom at first until the plot threw me for a loop as to who it really was. That was a nice plot twist there.

Dareka no Manazashi is typical Shinkai fare, but not everything was brilliant. While the animation looked crisp and the scenery was great, I thought there were too many shortcuts taken in the animation department. There were way too many still shots for a film this short. I know Comix Wave is better than this and as much as I found The Garden of Words to be extremely overrated, no one can argue that the animation was a quantum leap better than this. I also wished that there was an extra few minutes. Dareka no Manazashi could’ve been better had this have been twice it’s length where one can expand on the family’s relationship (particularly the mom) or see some of the details at the characters’ jobs instead of just flying right by it with numerous stills and exposition. I was also underwhelmed by the music. It wasn’t bad per se, but I would’ve liked to have heard more effort with the score since I know all of Shinkai’s films had great music to accompany the visuals.

This little short film was like an abridged work of Makoto Shinkai which certainly wasn’t bad. There was a decent amount of character development and the subplot with Mii was certainly heartwarming. While there was some good CGI and scenery, I thought there was too little animation used for a good portion of this short film. Dareka no Manazashi is a decent and painless watch, but I know Shinkai has been capable of more.


Adjustable Point System:

Add 1 point if you’re a Makoto Shinkai fan.
Add 1 point if you like kitties.
Subtract 2 points if you care about flawless animation.

Pros:
-Heartwarming story
-Nice plot twist with the narrator
-Great CGI and scenery

Cons:
-Overabundance of stills
-Rushed pacing in the short allotted length
-Lackluster musical soundtrack

Final Score: 7/10 points



Content Warning: This is a fairly safe film for most people to watch. The only issue was the scene where (spoiler alert) a pet dies, but it’s done off-screen. Dareka no Manazashi is safe for all audiences.

-Curtis Monroe

All photos property of their respective owners and used under US “Fair Use” laws.

4 comments

  1. This was short and sweet. I really enjoyed it! I found the drama to be pretty relatable.
    I’m not sure if I understood the purpose of the futuristic technology though. It’s there, but it’s not explained or developed in any way. I guess high-tech futuristic settings can add to a feeling of isolation, but I thought they could totally have expanded on that or taken it out altogether.

    Liked by 1 person

    • I agree. Dareka no Manazashi was a pleasant short film from Shinkai. It is also strange given its ties to a real estate company in Japan. That’s a good point about the futuristic aspect. I thought it was gaudy even though it looked cool. You can replace it with tablets and smartphones and it would have made more sense. Come to think of it, Dareka no Manazashi would’ve worked better as a modern day story. At least with Voices of a Distant Star, it took place decades in the future and there was a clear cut reason why there was advanced technology even though the cell phones look really dated now.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s