Mary and the Witch’s Flower Review

Image result for mary and the witch's flower

AKA: Mary to Majo no Hana, The Little Broomstick
Genre: Fantasy/Adventure
Year Released: 2017
Distributor: GKIDS/Universal

Origin: Japan
Running Time: 103 minutes

Rating/Recommended Audience: PG
Related Films/Series: N/A
For Fans Of: Kiki’s Delivery Service, Harry Potter series, Little Witch Academia, The Secret World of Arrietty, Petite Princess Yucie, Card Captor Sakura, Ponyo, The Chronicles of Narnia
Notes:
-The Japanese language track was used for this review.
Fun Facts:
-Mary and the Witch’s Flower is the debut work from Studio Ponoc. This newer animation studio was founded by ex-Ghibli animators Hiromasa Yonebayashi (the director of this film) and Yoshiaki Nishimura (the producer).

-Speaking of Hiromasa Yonebayashi, he’s the youngest person to direct a Ghibli film at the age of 37 with The Secret World of Arrietty during his tenure at that studio.

-Mary and the Witch’s Flower is based on a book called The Little Broomstick which was written by British author Mary Stewart (notice her first name in regards to this film).

-Mary’s VA Hana Sugisaki also played Rukia in the recent live-action remake of Bleach. Yes, that actually happened.


I’m often lost when it comes to newer animation studios. It seems as though many of them have popped up this decade or some of them I just haven’t paid that much attention to such as White Fox, Wit Studio, A-1, or Trigger (Leave me alone, otaku!). One studio that did get my attention was Ponoc (pronounced Poh-noche). At the time of this review, they’ve only made two films, but they certainly got notice since it was made by ex-Ghibli employees. Since Ghibli are such the critical darlings with both anime fans and film buffs, they would certainly get notice once they would release their debut film.

How well does this debut work for Ponoc?

Mary and the Witch’s Flower takes place in the British countryside and the main character in question is Mary Smith. She recently stays in her Great Aunt Charlotte’s house, but she has trouble adjusting to this area. Mary has no friends, is too clumsy for her own good, and feels that she’s useless despite wanting to show that she’s adept. On one day, she discovers a mysterious flower called the fly-by-night from a local gardener and eventually finds a broomstick that can actually fly as she follows the cats of Peter (one of the boys who teases her). Mary finds herself far away to a place called Endor College which is an elite school for magicians. She meets the headmistress Madame Mumblechook who gives her a campus tour where she’s exposed to magic-infused technology rivaling that of sci-fi movies. Mary tries out some spells which causes Mumblechook and her associate Dr. Dee to believe she’s the ultimate magical prodigy. Things start out interesting until Mary discovers a hidden magic book that belongs to the headmistress. Mumblechook finds out about Mary knowing about this book and her feelings towards the girl change. Back home, Peter is kidnapped and the only way to get him back is to go back to Endor.

This film certainly has some interesting things that caught my attention. I know Mary can start out as a typical clumsy heroine for several viewers, but she was likable enough to root for as a protagonist. I do share her feelings of wanting to prove my worth to everyone else even when things go wrong. She does develop into a better heroine later on which I certainly appreciated. I also enjoyed the soundtrack of this film. Sure, I didn’t expect to hear so much hammered dulcimer, but I really liked the score and that instrument was certainly unique while being featured. The animation was certainly fluid which is to be expected from ex-Ghibli animators and they were certainly competent with the technical aspects in the visual to make sure everything flows in this movie. The magitech aspects certainly looked great and surreal like some PG version of Paprika.

While Studio Ponoc put effort in making sure things look good and sound good, I wish I could say the same for the rest of this film. There were plot holes with the world building and there was no development for anyone in Endor besides Mumblechook and Dr. Dee. I also found a whole heaping of unoriginality going on. Mary and the Witch’s Flower was like an anime attempt at making Harry Potter and other things. The fact that there is a Philosopher’s Stone didn’t help matters (one can also insert a Fullmetal Alchemist joke for that situation). Even Endor College was like a mix between Hogwarts, Redwall, Narnia, Agartha from Children Who Chase Lost Voices, and even Angel Island from the Sonic games. Some plot points were so predictable like Mumblechook having devious plans for Mary. Another predictable aspect that I called long before it happened was the revelation who the original red-haired witch was. As soon as one character picked up the flower and knew what it was, I instantly called it. They even resort to resurrecting tears like that cheesy scene from Pokemon: The First Movie in the third act which was facepalm-worthy.

The biggest aspect that hurts Ponoc as a studio is that it’s trying WAY too hard to be like the founders’ former company. The movie even starts out with a static title shot of their company which might as well be Mary replacing Totoro as she faces to the left. The character designs and animation style while still high-quality still looks like Ghibli. I really would’ve liked to have seen more effort to really differentiating themselves from Miyazaki’s shadow and trying to carve their own identity. Say what you will about studios such as Pierrot, Sunrise, or Madhouse. Those companies got started by ex-animators from different studios and made themselves look and feel different from their original employers.

I just found Mary and the Witch’s Flower to be an average debut for a new studio. There are things to like such as the animation quality, music, and Mary as a character. I’ve certainly seen much worse in terms of fantasy, but I didn’t see this movie moving the needle in that genre. I felt that the film was hindered by unoriginality and by playing it safe by mimicking Ghibli more than trying to be more unique. Ponoc is still new and I want them to do good things, but Mary and the Witch’s Flower didn’t feel so magical to me when I watched it.


Adjustable Point System:
Add 1-2 points if you really like magic and wizardry in movies
Add 1 point if you’re a fan of Hiromasa Yonebayashi’s work
Subtract 1-3 points if you really care about originality

Pros:
-Technical animation work
-Great soundtrack
-Mary is a good protagonist

Cons:
-Plot holes and predictable plot points
-Way too much Ghibli copycatting
-Lack of interesting characters



Final Score: 5/10 points


Content Warning: Mary and the Witch’s Flower is a safe watch for families like a good portion of Ghibli movies. There is magic used, but it’s closer to Narnia than anything really occult-like in my opinion. There is some disturbing implications as there’s human and animal experimentation done by Mumblechook and Dr. Dee. One flashback even reveals that a child even died during one of the original experiments which is the darkest moment of this film.

-Curtis Monroe

All photos used under US “Fair Use” laws. Mary and the Witch’s Flower is property of Studio Ponoc, GKIDS, and Universal. The DVD cover is from IMDb and is property of GKIDS and Universal.

5 comments

  1. I’ve been seeing some very mixed reviews for this film. Some people highly enjoyed it, some people were more along the lines of your post. I haven’t seen this one just yet so I can’t judge yet, but I am going to be watching at some point. Nice to see a new anime review from you again! Terrific post, sorry the movie didn’t really work for you though.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Same here. It’s gotten mostly positive reviews in regular critic circles, but the anibloggers have been more critical from what I’ve seen. I didn’t think Mary and the Witch’s Flower was terrible, but I wish it could’ve been so much better. I wish Ponoc would carve out their own identity first instead of resting on Ghibli’s laurels.

      Thanks, Raistlin. This is a temporary hiatus break since I wanted to post three reviews on my birthday as a gift to those that appreciate my commentary on movies, anime, whatever.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s