Children of the Whales Review

Children of the Whales

AKA: Kujira no Kora wa Sajo ni Utau, Whale Calves Sing on the Sand

Genre: Fantasy/Drama/Post-Apocalyptic
Year Released: 2017
Distributor: Netflix

Origin: Japan

Running Time: TV series, 12 episodes, 23 minutes each

Rating/Recommended Audience: TV-MA
Related Films/Series: Children of the Whales (OVA)

For Fans Of: Last Exile, Haibane Renmei, Saikano, Waterworld, Now and Then Here and There, Nausicaa
Notes: 

-The Japanese language track was used for this review.
Fun Facts:
-Children of the Whales is based on an ongoing manga written by Abi Umeda which is serializing in Monthly Mystery Bonita.

-The childish and sadistic soldier Ryotari is voiced by Daiki Yamashita. He’s the same VA who provides the voice of Izaku Midoriya from My Hero Academia. Sweet dreams whenever you see Ryotari slaughtering people with a smile on his face with his Thymia quirk.

-Children of the Whales was directed by Kyohei Ishiguro whom you might know for his work in directing Occultic;Nine and Your Lie in April.

-In addition to performing her own music, singer Rionos (who sang the ending theme “Hashitairo”) did composition and arrangement work for themes songs in other anime. Some of her outside musical work involves co-writing songs for anime such as Miss Kobayashi’s Dragon Maid, Maquia, and Hanebado.


Anibloggers can rejoice that I decided to take on a newer anime series. I know that I’m not as well-versed when it comes to anime made in the 2010s, but I do my best to give a critical eye while being as equal as I can like I would with anything made in the 00s and before. I do have to credit Jon Spencer after checking out his review of this same series while also him nudging me a bit to watch some of it. Even other peers such as Karandi and Scott have checked out this series, too. This particular anime also provides an Iridium Eye first. If I’m not mistaken, this is the first time I review a shojo series which I didn’t even know was part of that demographic until researching after watching the entire TV series.

I think you had enough of me with that preamble. Let’s dive into this sandy sea for this mysterious anime.

Children of the Whales takes place in a strange post-apocalyptic environment where there are entire oceans of sand around. There’s a giant ship called the Mud Whale that carries hundreds of people living in this vessel as it traverses water and sand alike. This mystical vessel has two main groups of people. There are the Marked who are individuals that use psychic/magic energy called Thymia, but they have drastically shorter lifespans where they live up to their twenties or thirties if they’re lucky. There’s the Unmarked who have no such powers, but they live normal human lifespans and are in several leadership positions on the Mud Whale. The main character is a Marked recorder/scribe named Chakuro who’s fourteen years old and never saw life outside of the Mud Whale. That all changes where him and his peers find an unknown island and he sees a mysterious blue-haired girl allegedly named Lykos (it was the only name they could see on her coat) who starts out dead silent. She’s actually from an enemy kingdom that targets the Mud Whale because of an enigmatic punishment which lead that community to be in exile for nearly a century. These communities harbor their own secrets and hidden histories while blood is being shed.

This was certainly a series with unique elements. I was impressed with the art style and animation provided by JC Staff. I know I haven’t been the kindest when it comes to that studio (See my reviews on Legend of the Last Labyrinth and Fight!! Spirit of the Sword), but when they try, they can be really good. So much of the movement is fluid, the action is creative with the Thymia powers, and the atmosphere has this surreal old-world feel while fusing elements of ocean punk, steampunk, and desert punk in one neat package. The art and backgrounds remind me of a mix between The House of Small Cubes, Haibane Renmei, The Tale of the Princess Kaguya, and Kino’s Journey which is a huge compliment from me. The music was a great choice with acoustic and symphonic elements. The ending theme is a very haunting acoustic/ambient piece that fits the mood of this series so much. The usage of music such as the insert song from Aima and the song the Mud Whale sings later in the series were also great. There were some interesting characters in Children of the Whales. The main character Chakuro didn’t seem like a typical anime protagonist to me. I can certainly relate to him being a writer, but he was more as his curiosity played a crucial role in the story, but he develops into a far more resolved character after seeing all the chaos around him or finding out the secrets about the Mud Whale. Lykos starts out as an emotionless blank slate (insert joke about the typical blue-hair emotionless girl effect like Rei Ayanami), but she slowly expresses herself in healthy ways as the series progresses. The relationship dynamic with her and Chakuro did keep me a bit interested. You also had the rebellious mole (prisoner) Ouni who is very powerful, but to stubborn for his own good. Not going to lie, he does look like a misplaced Avatar: The Last Airbender character, but he becomes so much more than that with his own reasoning or where his loyalty lies.



Children of the Whales does get beached more times than I could count though. While the world building was very fascinating, the anime series is not consistent with all of the world’s rules. The fact that emotions or the lack thereof play into different societies, it was bizarre when the Allied Empire who frown upon emotions have Orca who certainly emotes smugness and especially Ryodari who is very emotional in his gleefully sadistic nature to kill people like he’s a mix between Dio from Last Exile and Dilandau from Escaflowne. They also don’t develop certain concepts such as the types of Marked people, the Nous, other nations, or why the world is full of sand. Much like Angel Beats!, I thought there were way too many characters to keep track of in just twelve episodes. Sure, a bunch of them die, but I barely remember everyone’s names. The usage of child soldiers on both sides was way more disturbing than I intended, and there are far better series who handled that concept like Now and Then Here and There. I noticed subtitle errors such as misspelled character names and the big song that the Mud Whale inhabitants sing doesn’t have all the subtitles. What really hurts was that the lyrics were plot-relevant. The biggest flaw of Children of the Whales is that there’s no resolution. If the ending was just a season finale, then I’d be far more forgiving, but even people who don’t know anything about the manga (this includes myself) can tell that there’s way more to the story than what they just showed. Sure, it technically ends on a more positive note with a sense of optimism, but so many things were unresolved. I wish they would make a sequel to this series especially since the manga is still going on.

This fantasy series had so much potential, but not all of it was realized. Children of the Whales did hook me in with it’s surreal and colorful world atop the Mud Whale, but I wished there was more effort in multiple fields. The production is certainly one of JC Staff’s better endeavors which I do appreciate. The lack of a true sense of resolution really hurt this anime especially since nothing has been confirmed about sequels or anything to make that series continue. The world building aspects were two fold with brilliant things and inconsistent elements. Children of the Whales was only good, but I’ve seen similar series handle topics and stories much better.


Adjustable Rating System:

Add 1-2 points if animation means a ton to you.
Subtract 1-2 points if you must have a complete story.


Pros:
-Unique animation and art style
-Great musical soundtrack
-Likable main characters

Cons:
-Subtitle errors
-Incomplete story
-Inconsistent world building factors

Final Score: 6/10 points

Content Warning: Children of the Whales may start out tame in the first episode, but things get far more adult starting with the ending of episode 2. The battles get shockingly bloody and the body count gets high. Even multiple children get killed onscreen which is quite disturbing. There’s some language which gets strong at points (Ouni really likes using the S-word in the Japanese version). There is partial nudity, but all of those scenes are self-censoring with hair or limbs covering certain body parts. There are adult themes such as child soldiers, suicide, genocide, and colonization in this anime.

-Curtis Monroe

All photos property of their respective owners and used under US “Fair Use” laws. Children of the Whales is property of J. C. Staff and Netflix. The poster is from My Anime List and is property of J. C. Staff.

16 comments

  1. My favorite part of the review was:

    “The childish and sadistic soldier Ryotari is voiced by Daiki Yamashita. He’s the same VA who provides the voice of Izaku Midoriya from My Hero Academia. Sweet dreams whenever you see Ryotari slaughtering people with a smile on his face with his Thymia quirk.”

    That gave me a good laugh XD I’m glad you enjoyed this one but all the negatives are certainly a bummer on this show for sure. Enjoyed the review 🙂

    Liked by 2 people

    • Hahaha! I’m glad you liked that particular fact about that anime. Watch as my otaku prowess get thrown out the window, but I’ve never seen MHA.

      I thought it was okay, but I knew that anime could’ve been so much better. Some of the anibloggers have told me that the manga is much better. Children of the Whales had the potential to be a 8 or a 9, but too many things hampered it.

      Liked by 2 people

      • MHA is pretty decent, but it takes a good while before it gets to what I would consider to be more than just decently enjoyable. Lot of recap and some other things I’m not huge on. Once it is actually moving, it feels great though.

        The manga looks really good so I can totally believe this. I enjoyed Children of the Whales well enough, but I definitely would have thought more highly of it had it been given more time to tell its story.

        Liked by 1 person

      • Gotcha. I’m hesitant given the massive hype around that series and Shonen Jump stuff can be hit or miss with me.

        That’s what I’ve heard. I’ve seen screenshots of the manga which look great and I know the story goes farther than the anime. It’s actually still going on right now with the manga, so they could’ve made multiple seasons/sequels on that TV series.

        Liked by 1 person

      • I’d say that it is probably worth checking out so long as you are comfortable buckling in for the long haul. Given that S4 is going to start relatively soon, I’m fairly confident that investing in it won’t be a let down since people seem committed to telling the whole story, or at least hitting a comfortable stopping point at worst.

        They hype issue I get though. I think going in with the expectation that things will be decent but get better over time will yield a positive result, but there are a lot of shows so don’t feel like you have to of course.

        Anyway, Netflix has a really bad habit of starting all sorts of random stuff and then abandoning it. Plus, after seeing their “documentary” on anime I’m pretty sure anything that a lot of their older “original” anime don’t fit the mold they are going for now with CG and edgy titles.

        Liked by 1 person

      • I see. Longer series are a harder sell especially given my review queue and my jobs which consumes a lot of time. I heard S4 was coming out really soon and the manga is still going on, so I know this is still going to be a thing.

        Yeah, that’s certainly a legitimate concern I have and not just because of my mindset and the concept of this blog.

        Yeah, I’ve been noticing that when I check out anime through Netflix. It’s sad because I know Netflix is better than this even with their original movies and documentaries while that anime “doc” looks atrocious. They can’t just rely on the CG stuff or the brand new anime series only for distribution (no, EVA isn’t enough). I wish they would work with more anime distributors for streaming and get older series, but that looks unlikely.

        Liked by 1 person

      • They have quite a few older titles actually. Recently acquired Anohana (and the new dub for it), they have things like Gunslinger Girl, etc… too. What’s advertised is more the issue, people just don’t know /what/ anime they have.

        Liked by 1 person

      • Yeah, I saw they had Anohana. I didn’t know they had Gunslinger Girl, too. Must not have been advertised as much. I feel like I would have to do a thorough search on the site to find all the anime they have instead of just relying on the DVDs.

        Liked by 1 person

  2. That’s how I feel about it too. It has potential to be amazing, but one flaw after another set it back. I still love it’s visual aesthetics and art design. It’s not something one forgets about.

    Liked by 1 person

    • No problem and it’s good that you feel the same way here. It was frustrating because I know this series could’ve been WAY better than what it was. J. C. Staff did an amazing job with the production, but I wished the writing and story would’ve matched that kind of wonder and art style.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. The incomplete nature is the worst part about this. There are definitely flaws and inconsistencies along the way but it is still a fascinating watch but leaving us seemingly mid-journey with no hope of seeing it continue just kind of kills this one in terms of being able to recommend it.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s